Film Review: ‘The Summit’ Chronicles the 2008 K2 Tragedy


Like most mountaineering tragedies the horrible events that occurred on K2 in August of 2008 left behind far more questions than answers. The Summit, a new documentary that hits movie theaters on October 4, puts into perspective the cumulative circumstances that led to the deaths of 11 climbers on the second highest peak in the world.

Described by one survivor in the film as “a day in a million” conditions for a successful bid to the summit were indeed perfect. But after a long siege of this Himalayan giant, tent-bound for days of inclement weather, the psychological pressure to reach the top when a window of opportunity finally opened may well have been the climbers’ undoing. Had they turned back when Serbian Dren Mandic fell and perished below the bottleneck just as they entered the Death Zone at 8,000 meters there may have been only one casualty.the-summit-movie-poster-550x815

Overcome, perhaps, with summit fever, the combined group of several different teams continued on despite the many dangers that unfolded with each passing hour. As time ran out and they attempted a night-time descent of the mountain into darkness, one catastrophe after another struck until 7 of the 18 climbers who reached the summit lay dead. And two more sent up from base camp were killed in the attempt to rescue them.

Photographed in excruciating detail through reenactments and actual footage recorded during the event, the Summit offers a graphic depiction of a life and death struggle to survive while exposed in one of the most hostile environments on the planet. Written by Mark Monroe and directed  by Nick Ryan the film is a true documentary that attempts to accurately and objectively portray a real story without speculation of root causes or assigning blame. Instead the audience is treated to an intimate view into the lives of passionate individuals in pursuit of their common goals. And in the telling of the story the character of each participant in the journey is allowed to unfold, revealing the nature of their motivation and the principles that guide their lives.

The roles of heroes and villains in this film are left to each viewer to assign for themselves. They may decide upon their own reckoning whether or not the risks of high altitude mountaineering are worth the rewards if any. But anyone watching this film must conclude that there is indeed a very high price to pay and in the end often no amount of climbing skill or preparation will matter in the Death Zone.

The Joy Trip Project is made possible thanks to the generous support of MAKO Surgical Corp. If you experience chronic hip or knee pain it might be time for a replacement. Ask your doctor if you’re a candidate for MAKOPlasty. I’m glad I did.

JamesMills_bioJames Mills is the mastermind behind The Joy Trip Project, a newsgathering and reporting organization that covers outdoor recreation, environmental conservation, acts of charitable giving and practices of sustainable living. The unabriged version of this article can be found at


Free PDF    Send article as PDF   

You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Leave a Reply

close comment popup

Leave A Reply